We Agreed On Experiencing Life, So Why Did You Immortals Become Real?说好体验人生，仙子你怎么成真了

《We Agreed On Experiencing Life, So Why Did You Immortals Become Real?》
— Review by Daoist Inkdrunkwanderer



This novel is a trickster’s promise and a poet’s dagger. On the surface, the premise is simple...the MC is meant to “experience” lives with different lovers. But the execution? Sharper than a jade hairpin.

Arcs: The first arc was short, light, and left me unsatisfied ....characters flickered in and out before you could even drink them in. But the second and third arcs? Pure nectar. Characters breathe, motives sear, and emotions spill. The dragon-girl arc in particular is so potent you could rip it out of the larger text and it would stand as a 5-star novella on its own. I was misty-eyed for chapters, Daoist Inkdrunk swears upon his broken gourd.

Flashbacks: Absolute bangers. They hit harder than the “present timeline,” which feels more like Assassin’s Creed filler ....cutaways where nothing happens except reminding you the MC still exists in the modern world. The novel is slow-burn, yes, but at times the burn feels uneven. Some arcs (second girl) are three or four times the length of others, yet both heroines stand equal in the modern setting. The imbalance is felt.

Structure: Unlike other reincarnation/life-experience stories where characters later “recover” the memories they built with the MC, here those memories already exist. He’s not living life....he’s reliving padded ones. It’s a subtle difference, but it makes the story feel more fated than organic. Whether you like that will depend on your taste in tea.

Drama: Some readers love it; others feel it stretches the broth too thin. Personally, I found parts of the drama overextended.... like a musician refusing to end the song when the strings are already breaking.

Cultivation World: Nothing groundbreaking, but neatly outlined: three lower realms, three middle, three upper. Transformation into dragons is staged from snake to jiao to true dragon.... tidy, familiar, functional.

Flaws: The reincarnation-from-modern-Earth element feels… unnecessary. Other than a small “cheat” in shaping the Confucian Dao, it’s not leveraged. One could erase his Earth origin entirely and the story would stand without wobbling. That makes the premise feel redundant, even wasteful.

Verdict:
This is not a novel for the impatient wanderer. It is a slow, indulgent, emotional wine. The highs (second arc, dragon-girl) are intoxicating ....the kind that leave your eyes red even after the jug is empty. The lows (pacing, modern timeline, redundant reincarnation setup) drag like muddy boots. But when it sings, it sings.

Daoist Inkdrunk raises his cracked gourd and says: if you are here for emotional knives wrapped in silk, stay. If you demand flawless pacing or consistent structure, you may choke on the lees.

🖋️ —Daoist Inkdrunk wanderer,
wanderer of taverns,
drinker of venom,
still waiting for Immortals to stop playing at drama and truly “become real.”

That's nice. I love dragon lady

Does anyone know how many is the total chapter? I haven’t read it but bookmarked it into “will read” and waiting if final chapter is coming early which then i will read but if took a long time then i”ll just wait and read other novels first

I was attracted by the lovely cover

NOOOOOOOOOOOO WHY DID I CATCH UP. WHYY ONLY 60 CHAPTERS. Very good novel made me get reary eyes few times.

It has been 3 years since I had created this account and 4/5 years since I have been reading novels online but there are only are a few novels that are able to bring me to tears and this has been one of them. Sure there may be many novels like or many like those simulation come true but the way this one has been written truly brings out the emotions from within of the reader. It is not rushed as of now neither does have a really bad plot but the writing style truly stands out. I have rarely written a review on this or any site but this one forced me to write it. Now this review is on the basis of current progress and lets hope it will remain the same in the future of this novel.
Note : Of course this is my opinion and how I felt from reading this novel , it may not be the same for everybody else but everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

Everybody copying the book of a hundred lives concept from Primordial Saint Sect. Smhhhh

It is a series that I would call a snack, but sometimes it is quite gripping. Recommended.

Caught up all the mtl translation, nothing mind blowing, typical hundred life thing, romance is decently written (expected to be since this a romance novel), sadly seems to going to be a harem, which is sad since I got attached to the dragon lady.

Nothing mind blowing but well executed, not much fault in logic and all, overall decent read to kill time, will continue reading.

Mtl translated is surprising very good and did not give me a qi deviation, slight differences in the jade realm, as mtl translation calls it Jade Pu realm and as I believe the other translated one is different.

Mtl is nearly as good as the human translated one.

The mtl of this is surprisingly just as good as the translated chapters.