Options
Bookmark

Chapter 456: Fate's Cruel Jest

Before father and son could react, they heard commotion from downstairs.

In that instant, both seemed to realize something.

Liu Zhiyue reacted first, rushing to the window and pressing his hands against the glass to peer down.

But he saw nothing.

Meanwhile, Liu Changqing left the hospital room directly, sprinting toward the stairwell.

He remained silent the entire way. Though his mind raced with terrible suspicions, based on his understanding of her character, she would never...

She had endured five years of suffering already. How could she...

How...

Breathless from the frantic dash downstairs, Liu Changqing's heart pounded violently in his chest.

When he spotted the crowd gathered not far away,

his footsteps gradually slowed...

until stopping completely.

Soon after, Liu Zhiyue caught up and stood beside his father. Upon seeing the distant crowd, he ignored his father entirely and bolted toward them.

This left Liu Changqing standing alone, staring in disbelief at the gathering.

His mind flashed back to Li Wanran's eyes when he'd visited her hospital room earlier—

those utterly lifeless eyes.

A woman so proud...

How could she choose this path?

——————————————

Approaching evening.

An Yuanyao, wearing an apron, carefully ladled soup into a thermos before sealing it tightly.

Just as she finished, her three children burst into the kitchen simultaneously as if prearranged, swarming around her.

Startled, An Yuanyao abandoned her task to steady the children.

"We're hungry!" they chorused.

"Starving!"

"Super hungry!"

Smiling gently, she patted Chun Nuan's head—the loudest complainer—and soothed,

"Just wait a little longer. Mommy hasn't started cooking yet."

"Mommy's lying! You said you were making soup!"

"Soup!"

"Yeah yeah, liar~"

Before she could console them, the front door opened.

An Yuanyao immediately recognized the sound—

her husband was home.

Abandoning the children, she rushed from the kitchen.

"Changqing, how's Wanran? Is she awake? I called you all morning but you never answered."

"......"

Seeing her husband frozen in the doorway, An Yuanyao's expression gradually stiffened.

She stepped closer.

"What's wrong? Hasn't she woken up?"

"......"

Instead of answering, Liu Changqing's complexion appeared drastically worse than when he'd left that morning—

exhausted...

and profoundly sorrowful.

"Changqing..."

"She killed herself."

"......"

His head lowered slightly as he spoke, then lifted to meet his wife's gaze—

her widened eyes.

His voice dropped to a terrifying whisper.

"She jumped... from the hospital."

"......"

An Yuanyao staggered backward as if her legs had failed, nearly collapsing before Liu Changqing caught and embraced her tightly.

"No... that's impossible..." she mumbled, her entire weight leaning into him.

Her eyes overflowed with disbelief.

"She'd never... someone like her would never..."

"I'm sorry."

"No..."

Hearing his wife's broken voice, Liu Changqing's heart ached with guilt.

His arms tightened around her.

The three children watched silently from a distance.

Liu Chunnuan had initially beamed upon seeing her father, preparing to run to him, but Liu Zhi'an grabbed her arm to stop her.

None approached.

They simply observed.

Though the Liu boys didn't fully understand, they recognized their mother's anguish—

her palpable pain.

Feeling his wife begin to sob against his chest, Liu Changqing said nothing, simply holding her closer.

Holding this grieving woman...

The woman Li Wanran had once hurt so deeply, yet who had somehow forgiven her over the years.

Just that morning, she'd reminded him she'd visit Wanran that evening—

bringing homemade soup.

Two childhood friends.

Elementary school together.

Middle school.

High school.

Such a bond...

Such companions...

"I'm sorry... truly sorry..."

At these words, An Yuanyao could no longer contain herself.

Tears she'd suppressed for years erupted in unrestrained wails as she clutched Liu Changqing's clothes desperately.

The children, affected by their mother's cries, soon joined in—Liu Chunnuan first, followed by the others.

Soon the entire house echoed with weeping,

drowning in...

sorrow.

Surveying the scene,

listening to the chorus of grief,

Liu Changqing lacked words to describe his emotions.

As a transmigrator who'd replaced the alcoholic Liu Changqing after his suicide,

he now witnessed another suicide—Li Wanran's.

In some twisted way, their fates mirrored each other.

Had Li Wanran not obeyed Ye Rong so blindly...

Had Li Zhengmao shown his daughter more warmth...

Perhaps she and the original Liu Changqing might have found happiness.

Perhaps he'd never have arrived in this world.

Embracing An Yuanyao,

Liu Changqing inhaled deeply...

and released

a soundless sigh.

——————————

After evening self-study, Liu Xiazhi returned home as usual, bracing for her younger brother's pranks.

But upon entering, she found no Liu Zhiyun waiting to ambush her—

only her older brother lying on the sofa.

Her college-attending brother, inexplicably home.

Dropping her backpack onto the sofa, she crouched beside him.

"Brother... why are you back?"

"......"

Only at her question did Liu Zhiyue remove the arm covering his eyes and sit up.

When Liu Xiazhi saw his bloodshot eyes—

as if he'd been crying—

panic gripped her.

"Brother! What happened?!"

"......"

For a long moment, Liu Zhiyue simply stared at her.

Finally, he answered in a hoarse whisper:

"She's dead."

Comments 10

  1. Offline
    + 10 -
    Wanran was a pitiful person, never knowing what true love was. Failed by both mother and father. I, for one, choose to believe that she probably transmigrated to that world to be with her loving husband and kids.
    #RIP LI WANRAN
    Read more
  2. Offline
    + 00 -
    Quote: Ostenberg
    Quote: Duplozauri
    Those who feel sorry for her - obviosly haven’t read the novella from the very beginning. Or maybe they did, but not payed enuff attention. Some people need it explaining that she was the cause of nearly all the misfortunes for the children and the MC? And the MC himself (the original character) also died because of her influence, on his life.

    There's this saying "There's no saint without a past, and no sinner without a future" nobody is justifying Wanwan she got what she sowed but you can't overlook the fact every bad thing she did was under the influence of her mother, divorcing MC, making her cheat on him, abandon her children everything was instructed by Ye Rong from start to finish just because she wanted to prove her dead husband wrong. Yes, Wanwan did all those things without care but that's because she's been her mother's doll all her life so her emotional attachment naturally became non-existent, it's been clear she was never allowed to become her own person.
    We finally got to see her growing as a person after these 5 years without Ye Rong, like having regret for what she did, saying thank you for small things etc. She deserved her redemption arc, not a perfect happy ending but atleast a somewhat happy ending.

    True
    Read more
  3. Offline
    + 21 -
    Quote: Duplozauri
    Those who feel sorry for her - obviosly haven’t read the novella from the very beginning. Or maybe they did, but not payed enuff attention. Some people need it explaining that she was the cause of nearly all the misfortunes for the children and the MC? And the MC himself (the original character) also died because of her influence, on his life.

    There's this saying "There's no saint without a past, and no sinner without a future" nobody is justifying Wanwan she got what she sowed but you can't overlook the fact every bad thing she did was under the influence of her mother, divorcing MC, making her cheat on him, abandon her children everything was instructed by Ye Rong from start to finish just because she wanted to prove her dead husband wrong. Yes, Wanwan did all those things without care but that's because she's been her mother's doll all her life so her emotional attachment naturally became non-existent, it's been clear she was never allowed to become her own person.
    We finally got to see her growing as a person after these 5 years without Ye Rong, like having regret for what she did, saying thank you for small things etc. She deserved her redemption arc, not a perfect happy ending but atleast a somewhat happy ending.
    Read more
  4. Online Offline
    + 04 -
    Those who feel sorry for her - obviosly haven’t read the novella from the very beginning. Or maybe they did, but not payed enuff attention. Some people need it explaining that she was the cause of nearly all the misfortunes for the children and the MC? And the MC himself (the original character) also died because of her influence, on his life.
    Read more
    1. Online Offline
      + 11 -
      Life isn't black or white. It's possible to hate everything a person's done and still feel sorry for them. Especially in this case. We know Wanran's backstory and she wasn't raised properly. Her mother saw her as a piece to use against her father and her father didn't establish any proper bonds with her. She grew up warped and while it doesn't excuse any of her actions, it does allow one to feel pity for her, especially since she showed remorse for everything she did. "What if she'd been raised well?"
      Read more
      1. Online Offline
        + 01 -
        Your argument suffers from a "false dichotomy". You present a false dilemma: either we must see a person as purely "evil," or we must pity them because of their backstory. This excludes a third, and more correct, option: "one can understand the reasons behind a person's criminality without feeling pity for them, while still holding them fully accountable for their actions." Understanding does not equal excusing or forgiving.

        Furthermore, there's a clear "confusion of explanation with justification". A difficult past and poor upbringing are explanatory factors; they answer the question, "How did she become like this?" However, they are not justificatory factors that answer the question, "Is she to blame for her actions?" Your thesis mistakenly uses explanation as a covert form of justification, equating "to understand" with "to forgive."

        The speculative question, "What if she had been raised well?" is irrelevant for judging the actual crimes committed. It shifts the focus from evaluating the deed to hypothetical circumstances, thereby eroding the very concept of personal responsibility.

        In short, the flawed premise of your text is that "understanding causation must necessarily lead to the moral outcome of pity." This is incorrect. Accountability for one's actions remains with the individual, irrespective of their past.
        Read more
  5. Offline
    + 11 -
    Truly sad. Didn't expect such a bitter ending for Li Wanran. Hopefully she wakes up in that parallel world peepo071 peepo071 peepo071

    Quote: Ostenberg
    Holy f#cking shit man! I did not wanted her to end up so miserable and was hoping for a redemption arc with a somewhat happy ending. The fact Wanwan was just like Xiazhi in her childhood means she could grown up to be a sweet person just like her. Both ye rong and her father are failures as parents. One used her as a tool for her own inferiority complex while the other just let it all happen and never acting like a father.

    Worst part she never even once met with Xiazhi in these 5 years, there last meeting being Xiazhi running away from her in fear. I was looking forward to their reunion and her apology to a grown up Xiazhi.

    Yeah same. Really sad ending for Li Wanran
    Read more
  6. Offline
    + 00 -
    Damn
    Read more
  7. Offline
    + 10 -
    It's reaaly a cruel fate

    Maybe, she's better this way, who knows
    Read more
  8. Offline
    + 31 -
    Holy f#cking shit man! I did not wanted her to end up so miserable and was hoping for a redemption arc with a somewhat happy ending. The fact Wanwan was just like Xiazhi in her childhood means she could grown up to be a sweet person just like her. Both ye rong and her father are failures as parents. One used her as a tool for her own inferiority complex while the other just let it all happen and never acting like a father.

    Worst part she never even once met with Xiazhi in these 5 years, there last meeting being Xiazhi running away from her in fear. I was looking forward to their reunion and her apology to a grown up Xiazhi.
    Read more